my case might be a bit complicated - I registered as ACCA member but I haven't passed any paper yet (I think as student, there is limitation how much I could do for company perhaps?); I recently started the ICB route and passed Level I basic bookkeeping. My goal in the near future is to be a self-employed bookkeeper, and I have no working experience in accounts at all.
Please if anyone could tell me what shall I do in order to achieve my goal?
P.S: I just started a new job in accounts department, but it seems they do not use sage or any of the account software, I think they only use Excel to deal with everything...do you think this job is worth keeping??? (I know how to use Excel and their purchsure looks complecated and I am sure a software would make people's work more productive... )
I kind of need to make an urgent decision now (today is my first day) so your advice will be mostly appreciated.
quite a few questions in there so sure I'll miss something in my response.
1) ACCA.
you would be restricted to bookkeeping to trial balance, Payroll and VAT and you would not be able to file any returns or register as an agent with HMRC.
This one was covered in great detail in this thread.
You really should read that link before continuing down the ACCA path.... Although if you do you will end up like me (don't know if that's a good or a bad thing).
Now the question that you have to ask is, will you be able to get the neccessary practical experience element required to become a member of the ACCA?
If the answer to that one is no then why face the restictions that membership will place on the services that you can offer? (Remember that the most draconian rules of any body that you are affiliated with take precedence over more lenient rules).
2) The role that you've taken in credit control may not seem very related to bookkeeping at the moment but just give it a while and you'll get used to tracking payments and recasting bank recs. etc.
Are the people that you are working for qualified accountants? If so theat reopens the potential for ACCA study so even though you may feel that you are not learning much now just working in a practice could open up opportunities to you.
3) I use Excel absolutely all of the time and much prefer it to any accountancy package. If it's not working at the site how you feel it should start automating processes and create Macro's to do things like produce the month end aged debtor reports.
Excel is one of those things that you can learn to use in an afternoon but not completely master in a lifetime. Personally I absolutely love it but that's just me.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Thanks for the link and I read almost all the posts comes with it. I now have a much clear picture about the rules and restrictions of ACCA, even I think there are still some grey area that still need to be clarified by ACCA regarding what a bookkeeper can and can't do while as being a ACCA student at the same time.
For family matters, I need to have flexible working hours and plus I always wanted to have my own business. I think I will resign ACCA for now and concentrate on my ICB studies to be a qualified bookkeeper, since this is the quickest way and I really do not want any trouble. Maybe when my boy gets older then I could pick up ACCA again if I am allowed. Now if I may ask for one more question: If I resign ACCA now, am I permitted to rejoin the association as a new student in the near future? (I guess I am just too greedy)
I now have resigned my new job (after only one day! It is amazing what a parent can do for their child). I only want to concentrate on my studies and to get things going more efficiently.
You are so helpful, really appreciated. (I think this forum and the people here is my best discovery this year!)
Even though ACCA is a great qualification to have, I think that for your circumstances you are making the right decision for where you are now. Such decisions get more difficult of course the more papers in that you are.
Think that we're both in similar boats over childcare and qualifications. I'm a single parent with sole custody. I thought that things would get easier as my boy got older but it's completely the opposit. Childcare really ceases to be an option from about the age of eight and whilst when he was young I could study when he slept (and indeed read accountancy texts to him as bedtime stories before he could talk!), now I spend the time that I need to be studying doing his homework with him as I'm sure that teachers, espechially maths and history teachers have absolutely no idea about the subjects that they teach our children.
My work takes me all over the country but I won't move my boy from school to school which is really putting pressure on me. I recently finished a gig in Edinburgh and his schoolwork suffered because I was only there at weekends and for half an hour on the mobile each night to explain to him what the teachers had failed to. That's no way for a boy to grow up so now living on reserves whilst finishing off ACCA and trying to suss how best to move forwards.
I started ACCA years back on the back of my banking work and I'm too close now to not go thorough the final hurdles but such has restricted my ability to offer a bookkeeping service to the point that I gave up my ICB membership earlier this year as I really could not justify keeping both it and the ACCA going. That was the right move for me as I have already invested too much time and effort to go through this all again. It wouldn't be the right move for you where for now sticking with the ICB opens far more revenue raising opportunities than ACCA.
ACCA is always more than happy to have people back but your problems are going then to be amplified. Imagine the scenario. You pass all of the ICB exams including level III, self assessment and Payroll. You are registered with HMRC to file returns, you give advice to sole traders, prepare management reports, etc.
As soon as you go back to the ACCA the stricter ACCA restrictions apply and all those things that you are quite capable of doing and have been doing for some time you are no longer allowed to do as an ACCA student.
Some on here say that they ACCA has shown flexibility in certain instances. Frauke and James have boith indicated that there has been past evidence of this. But, when you call them you get the same answer that until you have an ACCA practicing certificate if you are registered with the ACCA the services that you can offer are extremely restricted.
Personally I would like to think that this will change but I feel that it won't.
All the best and glad that you enjoy being part of our merry little band on here,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I have read lots of your other posts here and I always read with a smile - obviously you have got great sense of humor.
I think I made my choice so quickly without any hesitation is because I am standing on the start point here, and yes you are right, such decision would be very hard if I was in the middle of passing the papers.
To be honest, after reading the debate posts about rules with ACCA, I just feel that as a large professional body, all the ACCA worries about is not to get into any serious trouble which could cause by its students - this is the key of their restriction rules to students. They made such rules without realizing this could along bring the negative impacts. But I think they have to keep it this way so therefore to protect their excellent reputations in the field and manage such large number of students, I mean all kinds of students good and bad. However I still admire ACCA and think this is a great qualification to achieve, I wish I could be in the studies as far as you are since you are so close now, I am sure you will get there fine.
My little boy is only 16 months old but I already miss the time when he was a little baby...it is not easy, but there is lots of fun too. Anyway, thanks for the comfort about his studying bits, I always thought things could get easier when he grows older but it seems it's the other way round...have to re-think a plan B perhaps?! But I don't think I will give up ACCA though, I will figure out a way to do it somehow.
I had a very exciting week last week: Monday Tuesday - interview; Wednesday - pass level I exam;Thursday - excited and started a new job; Friday - resigned the new job and organize children's party at weekend... isn't life wonderful to live:)
Good luck with your studies, I am sure you will feel everything is worth for it once you pass all the papers and stand as a proud accountant! And your boy will be impressed too!
I am part qualified ACCA as well, after reading comments about ACCA on this forum I got curious and decided to call them today myself.
ACCA has no problem whatsoever with their students who are practicing qualified bookkeepers under other recognised bodies such as ICB, IAB etc. As long as that student practices solely under that body's licence with absolutely no practice reference to ACCA - ie the student cannot say he is practicing because he is soley an ACCA student.
That is to say, ACCA only gives practice licences to fully qualified members not student members. And because ACCA is an association of accountants, it is only reasonable for them to award licences to qualified members (who have earned this qualified accountant status by fully completing the acca exams) and not to bookkeepers.
So, as long as a licenced bookkeeper who happens to be an ACCA student practices with the provisions of his bookkeeping licence, he has absolutely no business with breaking ACCA's by-laws so far as he does not claim his licence to practice is from ACCA.
ACCA even went on to say(in our conversation today) that, a student has full rights to work in a bookkeeping capacity to trial balance for an employer but not in his own practice as ACCA licenced.
These to me makes sense.
Steve.
-- Edited by AccountFiles on Friday 27th of May 2011 02:52:26 AM
not a lot of time at the moment but I'll pad thjis out more later.
I think that we're slightly at cross purposes here.
It's the services that a PQ ACCA is allowed to offer as a bookkeeper, not whether or not they can work as a bookkeeper.
ACCA have no problem with you having dual memberships but you are still restricted in the services that you can offer to the basics :
Bookkeeping to trial balance, Payroll VAT
And according to other correspondence with ACCA you cannot register with HMRC as an agent.
The conversation was never in relation to the ACCA practice licence for which one needs three years (two in some limited circumstances) applicable post qualification work under a suitably qualified accountant.
As I said, I fill this out properly after the school run but for now, ACCA don't seem to have told you anything that isn't in regulation 8.
Talk in a bit,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
right, to continue. Think best that we approach this by going through your note point by point.
ACCA has no problem whatsoever with their students who are practicing qualified bookkeepers under other recognised bodies such as ICB, IAB etc. As long as that student practices solely under that body's licence with absolutely no practice reference to ACCA - ie the student cannot say he is practicing because he is soley an ACCA student.
No problem with that statement. That's talking about one's ability to practice as a bookkeeper, not what services one is allowed to offer
That is to say, ACCA only gives practice licences to fully qualified members not student members. And because ACCA is an association of accountants, it is only reasonable for them to award licences to qualified members (who have earned this qualified accountant status by fully completing the acca exams) and not to bookkeepers.
As mentioned in my first reply, to get the ACCA practice licence one needs to have three years post qualification under a suitably qualified accountant (ACCA, ICAEW, etc.).
So, as long as a licenced bookkeeper who happens to be an ACCA student practices with the provisions of his bookkeeping licence, he has absolutely no business with breaking ACCA's by-laws so far as he does not claim his licence to practice is from ACCA.
This is where I think that you misunderstood what the ACCA was saying. By being a member of another body such as the ICB or IAB does not mean that you can disregard regulation 8 which states that the services that you are allowed to offer as a student member are restricted to :
Bookkeeping to trial balance
VAT
Payroll
Which is less than the services that you would be able to offer as a bookkeeper under one of the afore mentioned supervisory bodies.
The real issue I found comes when clients want advice and you are not allowed to give it as such is properly deemed to be the work of an accountant, not a bookkeeper.
ACCA even went on to say(in our conversation today) that, a student has full rights to work in a bookkeeping capacity to trial balance for an employer but not in his own practice as ACCA licenced.
I think that rather than adding this as an extra snippet of information the person that you were talking to at the ACCA was really emphasising that as a bookkeeper you can only go up to trial balance.
Also, that last line makes little sense as if you are working for a qualified employer you are working in a supervised capacity and can pretty much do the full work of an accountant and would not be restricted to trial balance. That would be the restriction for a PQ working in an unsupervised capacity as a bookkeeper.
Again, that's all there in regulation 8.
Actually, maybe they were talking about on going to trial balance in the situation where you are working for an employer who is not a qualified accountant... No, that can't be right as when I was offered such a role the ACCA told me point blank that I could not accept the role because the employer was not sufficiently qualified to employ an ACCA student in an accounts practice capacity.
I would like to be proven wrong but I think that in this instance there may have been a gap either between what the ACCA were saying and your understanding of it, or the understanding of the wording of regulation 8 of the person at the ACCA that you were talking to.
I've also spoken to them directly (and got a quite different response) as did GinnyBee who got a similar answer to me plus that absolute gem from them about us not being able to even register as agents with HMRC (see the link from the first post above).
I think that if you spoke with someone else at the ACCA you may get a quite different interpretation of the ACCA rules.
Personally, unless I had something evidenced in writing from the ACCA confirming otherwise I would not do anything that regulation 8 did not permit me to.
I know that I'm disagreeing with you here but all of the above is intended to come accross contructively. I really hope that it is reads that way.
kind regards,
Shaun.
P.S. good luck in June. Which one's are you sitting this time?
P.S.2 edited because as usual I can't spell!... Think that there's probably still a few more gramatical errors hiding in there but sure that you get the general gist of what I'm saying.
-- Edited by Shamus on Friday 27th of May 2011 09:43:51 AM
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Before one wishing to progress from ICB (or what have you) achieves a full ACCA status, he must be at some point a part qualified. As he walks towards a full ACCA status, he does so silently while still practicing with his ICB practice provisions without claiming practice rights from ACCA.
Except you are saying that as a member ICB or IAB, you are not allowed to progress higher for an advance qualification such as ACCA?
It is like having a driver's licence for you car which enables you to drive freely; and you intend to go a step further for a truck driver's licence. DVLA would never have a problem with you for going for a truck driving lesson so long as you dont jump into a truck and start driving whilst you are still learning, and claim you are driving cos you think you can drive well without a truck licence. While you may be learning how to drive a truck, you have absolutely no problems whatsoever driving your car for which you have licence to.
The only aspect I disagree with you is the fact that you said that ACCA students holding practice licences from other bodies are limited. Ofcourse ICB licence holders are naturally limited by the nature of their professional curriculum which only allows them to do things you have listed previously. If an ICB member sticks with the provisions of his licence and training, he is absolutely fine even though he still studies ACCA.
What ACCA frowns at is when you claim to offer public services solely or jointly under her while you are still her student. They dont and cannot restrict what ICB allows me to do simply because I am their student when in fact I dont claim my right to practice as being given by ACCA or parade myself to the public as ACCA licenced practitioner.
I hate this restrictions but that's just the way it is.
The following is an extract from ACCA regulation 8 from the address below:
http://www2.accaglobal.com/students/rules/rights
(2) Permitted activities of ACCA students
(a) ACCA students of the Association may not claim to be members of the Association, nor may they be, or hold themselves out to be, in public practice, or a partner, director or controller of a firm or a member of a limited liability partnership which carries on public practice. ACCA students are, however, permitted to provide basic bookkeeping services for reward, either directly to the public or for an accountant, provided that they do not refer to their studentship or potential membership of the Association. Such service may be provided by the ACCA student acting in a self-employed capacity, or as an employee. Basic book-keeping services are defined as:
(i) The recording.......
The surmary of all these is that as an ACCA student, you are permitted to offer bookkeeping services directly to the public, but they cannot give you a practice licence to do so.
This article does not restrict my freedom to being a member of other bodies or getting their practice licence to deliver services allowed by such qualifications.
Sorry, don't think that you are reading my posts right :
You said : Except you are saying that as a member ICB or IAB, you are not allowed to progress higher for an advance qualification such as ACCA?
I said : ACCA have no problem with you having dual memberships but you are still restricted in the services that you can offer to the basics
The problem is not that you cannot be a member of the ICB in fact many ACCA students are members of the ICB (I was for quite a while) but the services that you can offer are restricted by your ACCA membership.
Take the example of ICB members who register with HMRC to file clients returns. As an ACCA student as GinnyBee was informed directly by the ACCA you are no allowed to be registed as an agent with HMRC so there's one situation where ACCA membership is restricting services that can be offered as a member of the ICB.
Nothing that I've said has ever indicated that the services offered would be under the banner of ACCA membership. That's just a given that you can make no reference to your student status.
The whole conversation relates to the the restrictions placed on ACCA students who have dual memberships not being able to perform all of the tasks permitted of ICB members who do not have dual memberships.
Regulation 8 is one of those that cannot be dipped into but must be viewed in its entirety.
To review (taken from the original post):
(2) Permitted activities of ACCA students
(a) ACCA students of the Association may not claim to be members of the Association, nor may they be, or hold themselves out to be, in public practice, or a partner, director or controller of a firm or a member of a limited liability partnership which carries on public practice. ACCA students are, however, permitted to provide basic bookkeeping services for reward, either directly to the public or for an accountant, provided that they do not refer to their studentship or potential membership of the Association. Such service may be provided by the ACCA student acting in a self-employed capacity, or as an employee. Basic book-keeping services are defined as:
(i) The recording of basic accounting data up to and including the preparation of accounting records to trial balance stage
(aa) bank accounts (bb) cash (cc) sales ledger and purchase ledger
(ii) Payroll
(aa) wages (bb) PAYE, National Insurance deductions
(iii) VAT or its equivalent.
(b) Any accountancy services, other than basic book-keeping services, can only be provided for reward by an ACCA student working for, and under the supervision of, a person who, in the opinion of Council, is suitably qualified and/or suitably experienced. The ACCA student may undertake such work either as an employee or as a self-employed person.
(c) The provision of basic book-keeping services directly to the public cannot constitute approved accountancy experience, for the purpose of regulation 3(a)(ii). However, basic book-keeping and other accountancy work undertaken under supervision may constitute approved accountancy experience.
(d) An ACCA student or affiliate who wishes to provide basic book-keeping services may obtain or seek such work by direct approaches to existing or prospective clients by mail or any other means unless prohibited by law in the country in which the student operates and subject to the requirements in paragraphs (e) and (f) below.
(e) An ACCA student may inform the public of his book-keeping services by means of advertising, or other forms of promotion, subject to the general requirement that the medium should not, in the opinion of Council, reflect adversely on the ACCA student, the Association or the accountancy profession, nor should the advertisement or promotion material, in the opinion of Council:
(i) as to content or presentation, bring the Association into disrepute or bring discredit to the ACCA student, firm or the accountancy profession;
(ii) discredit the services offered by others whether by claiming superiority for the ACCA students services or otherwise;
(iii) contain comparisons with the services offered by others;
(iv) be misleading, either directly or by implication;
(v) fall short of the requirements of the Advertising Standards Authority as to legality, decency, honesty and truthfulness.
(f) Advertisements and other promotional material may refer to the basis on which fees are calculated, or to hourly or other charging rates, provided that the information given is not misleading.
(g) Where ACCA students provide services pursuant to the above rules, they are subject to the same rules of professional conduct which apply to members who provide such services.
(h) Regulations 8(2)(a)(g) do not apply to ACCA students:
(i) who are members of one or more of the UK or Irish Institutes of Chartered Accountants, The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants or The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accounting and who hold practising certificates or the equivalent status from such bodies; or
(ii) who are authorised for appointment as company auditor under Section 25 of the Companies Act 1989; or
(iii) who are resident outside the United Kingdom, Jersey, Guernsey and Dependencies, the Isle of Man and the Republic of Ireland, and hold a professional accountancy qualification which confers the right to practise in their country of residence.
ACCA students falling within these categories are permitted to engage in public practice (although, in respect of category (iii), in their country of residence only) provided that they describe themselves only as members of the professional bodies to which they belong (if any) and not as students of the Association.
Note that 2(a) alone supports your arguement but in the context of the whole regulation 8 a different picture emerges. We cannot cherry pick the parts of a regulation that we wish to adhere to.
Hope that this makes my position clearer.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
You always can do CFAB (this is the first 6 mods of ACA) with ICAEW/ACA, on that way there is no restrictions there at all and if you complete it you can carry on to ACA with automatic exempt for the 6 mods you completed in CFAB and no entry requirements either. Ok once you start with actual ACA there are the same restrictions as with ACCA but after CFAB you would have a bit clearer picture if it is really for you or not or do you really want to go all the way to be chartered. I just thought I don't actually know if ACCA would give you any exemptions for CFAB...
I don't know If I'm replying on this a bit late - but I could really do with a bit off advice from you shamus.
I thought I had everything planned out but it seems you do not value the ACCA route that much?
Basically I am 17, not got the best GCSE's because I had a hard time at school, I did get 4 GCSE's A-C's and three of them consist of Maths, English and Science. I did a business course for a year, I got a BTEC certificate for that as I didn't complete the full course due to wanting to change my route - go into accounting - But I got distinction in that.
I am now going on to study level two and three this September - that is a year long commitment. My plan then was to get an apprenticeship therefore gaining experience and still studying in order to complete my level four, this would take just over a year. Providing I got them qualifications which I would expect to I was then planning on moving out of home and becoming an accountants assistant I think it is? Hopefully earning anything over £20000, I would expect to commit myself to doing this for three years, for these three years I would be studying the ACCA in my own time and would hope to be ACCA qualified by that time.
Therefore I would be ACCA qualified, AAT qualified(over-shadowed by the ACCA of course) BTEC Business certificate, four GCSE's (three in main subjects) and then also have four years accounting experience.
Please Please Please could you tell me if you think this is a good route and what I should be aiming to do for the next 5 years really. Am I seeing things to black and white? Plus im hoping for a salary of £15000 as an apprentice £22000 as an accountants assistant And £40000+ once fully ACCA qualified (5 years down the line).
I don't know If I'm replying on this a bit late - but I could really do with a bit off advice from you shamus.
I thought I had everything planned out but it seems you do not value the ACCA route that much?
Basically I am 17, not got the best GCSE's because I had a hard time at school, I did get 4 GCSE's A-C's and three of them consist of Maths, English and Science. I did a business course for a year, I got a BTEC certificate for that as I didn't complete the full course due to wanting to change my route - go into accounting - But I got distinction in that.
I am now going on to study level two and three this September - that is a year long commitment. My plan then was to get an apprenticeship therefore gaining experience and still studying in order to complete my level four, this would take just over a year.
Providing I got them qualifications which I would expect to I was then planning on moving out of home and becoming an accountants assistant I think it is? Hopefully earning anything over £20000, I would expect to commit myself to doing this for three years, for these three years I would be studying the ACCA in my own time and would hope to be ACCA qualified by that time.
Therefore I would be ACCA qualified, AAT qualified(over-shadowed by the ACCA of course) BTEC Business certificate, four GCSE's (three in main subjects) and then also have four years accounting experience.
Please Please Please could you tell me if you think this is a good route and what I should be aiming to do for the next 5 years really.
Am I seeing things to black and white?
Plus im hoping for a salary of £15000 as an apprentice
£22000 as an accountants assistant
And £40000+ once fully ACCA qualified (5 years down the line).
All of the major debates on here relate to people taking up studing ACCA whilst working as bookkeepers in their own businesses. This combination causes major issues because of the ACCA's rules on what their students are allowed to do.
Lets clear that up in relation to your circumstances for starters. You are not looking at self employment. You are looking at an apprenticship so the ACCA restrictions of regulation 8 do not apply to you.
You open by stating "you do not value the ACCA route that much".
On that one you couldn't be further from the truth. I actually regard the ACCA qualification very, very highly. They are my supervisory body although I have still not completed all of the exams yet. The qualification to my mind is second to none and if you can get past all of the experience requirements gaining it will be a big step in your career aspirations.
Right, now down to specifics.
You are talking about two years to complete AAT. From your timesscales I am assuming that you are considering taking on AAT and ACCA at the same time. Thats actually not a bad plan although I would try to tie in the ACCA papers to the AAT ones that you are studying for.
For example when you are doing the AAT tax papers do ACCA paper F6 Taxation. When doing company accounts do ACCA paper F5 Corporate reporting. When doing costing and budgets do paper F9 etc.
Level III AAT knowledge should help towards all of the ACCA papers however, after paper F3 you will notice a quantum gap between AAT and ACCA level studies.
On the ACCA front you state five years but you should set your plans based on 5-10 years as the complexity of th exams increases the further that you get in. Completing up to paper F9 is the equivalent of a BSc. but papers P1 to P7 are at MSc level.
I'm sure that you've noticed that 50% is a pass mark for an exam however, have you also noticed that some exams only have around 28% of students gaining a pass mark! Even if you go into the exams knowing the subject the time pressure on getting the answers down on paper in 3 hours (plus 15 minutes reading time) is intense.
Ok, onto your apprenticship. You need to ensure that the company employing you is qualified in the eye's of the ACCA so the you can get your PER signed off. Have a look on the ACCA website at the PER requirements and ensure before taking a position that all aspects will be covered during your apprenticship. Note that once qualified as ACCA you will still need to do a further two years post qualification in a training position in order to gain a practice certificate if yiu wanted to set up on your own.
On the money front. I think that your figures are slightly out. Here are the figures from the Hayes salary survey for Midlands based employee's. (Note that the figures that you quote are achievable in greater London but you would need to factor into your plans travel and / or accomodation in the capital).
A level Trainee (12000 to 16000) Graduate trainee (15000 to 21000) AAT Studier (21000 to 24000) Assistant Accountant (23000 to 26000) PQ ACCA/CIMA 1-2 years exp (19000 to 24000) PQ ACCA/CIMA 3-4 years exp (23000 to 27000) PQ ACCA/CIMA 5+ years exp (27000 to 32000)
Source, Hayes survey as given in PQ Magazine. March 2011.
Note that there is a difference between the role of accounts assistant and assistant accountant, the latter basically being an accountant in everything but name. The former being more towards the bookkeeping skills side of things.
There will of course be local variations and you should not pass up the right apprenticship merely because your salary demands are too high for the role. Always remember that there are more people wanting to be aprentices than there are roles available so taking a loss leader may pay dividends in the longer term.
There will be potential for greater income if you decide to open your own practice once fully qualified with your two years post qualification experience.
Hope that this helps to set your expectations at a more realistic level for your journey towards a fantastic qualification to have under your belt.
Please feel free to ask any specific follow up questions that I will be happy to answer.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Well, firstly I am going to study then AAT for two years and then the ACCA after. However I heard to become a chartered accountant or 'certified' then it will take around three years, 2 years if you really try? You say 10 years? -_-
And everywhere I have looked a certified chartered accountant can expect around £50000?
I am really nervous now because those figures you said and time lines are really really not what I expect to be doing.
Ill state my plan more clearly from what I have read and seen everywhere.
I would study Level 2 & 3 In this coming school year.
I would then move on to level 4 and do this as an apprenticeship, therefore gaining experience and money. I would expect to be on anything from £12000 - £18000 a year for this. This would take around 14 months as there is a summer holiday in between thus not being able to complete the study.
I would then plan to move out of home and live in Milton Keynes and work as a Assistant Accountant/Accountant assistant Ill have to look into which one it is that i looked at, whilst working here I would be studying and doing my ACCA qualification. Id expect to be doing this for THREE years as I have read thats how long it takes to become qualified as a certified chartered accountant. I would expect to be on anything between £20000 - £26000 at this stage.
Once I am qualified I would have four years experience in accounting practice and that would set me up for a better chance of landing the job.
What you have said seems to be so different to the information I have found.
I'm really not wanting to burst your bubble but ACCA is a very significant commitment in your life and it's well respected largely due to the large number of candidates that give up and drop out along the way.
If you feel that you can do ACCA in 2-3 years and command £50k at the end of that then go for it and I wish you the very best of luck. Don't forget to keep us all informed how your doing.
Your plan in your second post seems more realistic than your first. (with the exception that achieving ACCA will take longer than you expect it to).
2 years to level 4 AAT (I think Achievable)
3 years further to ACCA (even taking examptions from AAT I think that this is pushing it)
4 years further to gain experience (quite a generous post qualification period)
So in 9 years time you may well, taking into account inflation as well as your marketability as a chartered certified accountant be taking in excess of £50k per year.
(I think that you should at least consider moveing 2 of the 4 years to gaining the ACCA qualification though. So work to 2+5+2 rather than 2+3+4.).
Good luck in your studies.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Hello cheers for the quick reply - I was actually meaning that I would already have four years experience in accounting rather than adding another four. I know I could do ACCA in three years and dont get wrong I would try my hardest. However I would allow for four years no doubt. Id be expecting anywhere over £40k if im honest.
So basically Im 17 now and If I worked extremely hard I believe by the time I am 22/23 I would be a fully qualified certified chartered accountant earning over £40k. OR potentientally 23/24.
Do you think that is possibly now? And realistic. Dont get me wrong I am not expecting to land a big job as soon as I get my qualification but id atleast be in the position to be accepted for it.
Thanks a lot for the replies. Good to speak to someone whos actually somewhat involved with it.
Wouldn't you be better going for an Accountancy Apprenticeship now, this would give you employment at around £100 per week at your age and day release to study to L3, you could then go on to Advanced Apprenticeship which will take you to L4. Your local Careers Office, Connexions or whatever it's called in your area should be able to help with this, ie find you a placement.
ignoring for now the time difference between what we see the ACCA qualification taking you to achieve, imagine the situation from the employers side of the fence.
You need to fill a position for an accountant. Would you pay a 23 year old £40k+ to fill a role that many qualified accountants with maybe ten+ more years experience would be willing to do for much less?
You are talking about a scenario where from nothing to fully qualified and experienced accountant will take only five years... I'm really not seeing it although I would like to be proven wrong.
Your best start point is going to be downloading the full Hays Salary Survey for 2011 which gives general advice as well as localised salary levels accross the full spectrum of finance roles. See here for the download page :
http://www.hays.co.uk/Forms/HAYS_393377
You just need to input a few details to access the full download.
hope that this helps,
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I think that Ben is actually looking for an apprenticship (see his first message) but I fear that he may have listened to the careers advisor at school and I think his expectations are a little higher than reality with prove (no knowledge or experience to a £50k account role at 23!).
However, I think that it's good that a 17 year old has taken the time to plan this and I really am fully behind his efforts even if my posts do not quite come across that way.
On the careers advisor thing, when I was in the sixth form I was already around six foot but because I had horses the careers advisor suggested maybe thinking about a career as a jockey!
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I agree careers advisors are not the best but the careers service do have links with industry/professions and are the way to go to gain the new form of apprenticeships. Employers rarely advertise apprenticeships they tend to take on apprentices when they are approached by either training providers or the careers service who take on 16-18 year olds leaving school without jobs or further education places (and get cash from the government for so doing). From what Ben has written it appears he is/will be self-funding his training for the L2 and L3 which if he knew where to go he could get by doing an apprenticeship and being paid £100 per week (minimum) with day release to do his training as well as the rest of the time having on-the-job training. Ben was looking at taking on an apprenticeship to do L4 when he will be 18 with a salary of £12,000 - £16,000. Personally, I feel with L2 and L3 under his belt he would still be looking at the lower end of that salary scale. We all know what accountancy firms pay and it's not high salaries!!!!!
Again expecting in excess of £40K at age 22/23 without a degree or much experience is a little naive. I know from experience that a 22/23 year old leaving university with a 2:1 Hons degree (having done a year out with a blue chip firm and then being taken on by them) earns £26,000.
All power to Ben's elbow if he thinks he can achieve this but, like you, I think it would be difficult for him to complete to L4 in 2 years and ACCA in a further 3 years. My friend's daughter did accountancy straight from A levels at 18 working for a firm of accountants and qualified when she was 27. She's now 31 and earns nothing like £40K!
I very much understand your point that I am not going to be the most employable however I will have all the abilities to be? So I would be very valuable to maybe another company in helping them deal with finances.
Are you saying Im wrong in the study time lines Ive gave in order to achieve the qualifications?
Please note I am not getting defensive I am just trying to argue what Im seeing so that I can gain your views as you are involved. :)
By the way I am not being naive. All the information I have gathered are from tutors and people in this position. I am currently working at Tesco and on a very good wage, therefore an apprenticeship now would not benefit me at all.
My tutors expect their students to gain the AAT level 4 in two years. I don't know if it has changed since you was at school but level 2 & 3 are done in one year. Level four is done in 13/14 months, so taking into consideration summer holidays It would be December 2013.
One student at my college currently doing an apprenticeship is on £18000. So I am being far from naive to suggest I will be on £12000 +. The norm from surveys is between £12000 - £16000.
I found your response quiet rude to suggest I have nothing backing up my plans. Almost everywhere I read people say ACCA can be completed in 3 years and 2 years if you really push it.
Everywhere I read a certified chartered accountant is on around £50000. So again I am being far from naive to expect £40000+. If one is willing to work for £30000 then that is their loss as the majority are earning much more. If I am expected to have 5 years accounting experience then I will already have 4 of those 5 by the time I plan to be qualified.
None of what I have said suggests I am going to be spot on and earn the top end of the salary but I am also going on the averages and placing the minimum wage around in my mind.
What would be the point in me expecting to be earning less than the minimum? Surely I would then have very little ambition and also be rather stupid.
I am currently at the age where I can focus on my work and not have other things to concerntrate on, like looking after children. Therefore I can push myself to get these qualifications in the time periods I have stated.
Why would I aim to get somewhere that offers a low salary?
It seems very much like you do not like the idea of someone young succeeding and being on the same salary as an elder adult with children?
Please don't say that my plans have come from thin air when I am infact basing it on many things I have read.
And also believe me someone coming out of University at this current time is finding it much harder to find jobs than others.
This is to Shelia by the way.
If you have solid grounds to go on that you can tell me I cant and therefore ADVISE me I should do something else then so be it.
Shaun - I have not listened to careers adivsors once. I don't believe they are any good just as much as you. Please not I am not expecting at 23 to be on £50000, but I would expect to be on £35000 + with the fact Ill be gaining maybe a few more years experience in order to be on a higher wage. And then hopefully progress on to a much bigger business maybe in the city.
Please reply both of you, just don't think my plans are coming from thin air.
It seems like I was being rude in the last paragraph I meant I dont believe they are any good in the same way you dont believe they are, not saying your not. And I always meant Note*
I don't think your plans are coming from thin air, you have researched what you want to do and where you see yourself and I have no doubt that eventually you will achieve these aims, however, like Shaun I feel the time in which you feel you can gain ACCA is optimistic as are your salary expectations at 23 with little experience. With AAT at level 4 you should be able to gain an apprenticeship somewhere on the salary scale you identify (£12,000 to £16,000) but even if you manage to gain ACCA in 3 years you will only have that 3 years practical experience and you will still need to be in a supervised role not being able to practice independently. Employers look at post qualification experience rather than training experience when taking on new employees and it is the post qualification experience that counts where salaries are concerned.
I have been a tutor and it is in the interests of the tutor to make the future appear as rosy as possible for the student as without students there would be no jobs for tutors. Teaching these days, particularly in post 16, is all about "bums on seats".
Please don't be discouraged as a career in accountancy like any other profession can be very lucrative, but, as in the other professions it takes time before the higher rewards come.
The "salaries" you seem to think are typical are not actually typical and they tend to be only for jobs in Central London. The majority of jobs advertised for qualified accountants £25-£35k a year, even now I see senior possitions only at the top end of this amount. The higher paid jobs tend to have 250+ applicants and only 1 person ever gets the job, so the majority have a choice - they either accept lower paid jobs, find a way to start their own business, or stay unemployed.
As someone who has earn't more than £50k a year working for a company in the past (and I am not chartered), but replaced a chartered who was only on £30k a year, I know they had no choice due to the limitations of what they brought to the job. The only reason I was paid more, was I had extra skills not normally accredited to an Chartered Accountant which I was able to use with the company in additional to the accountancy skills they required.
Would agree that to expect +£40k for a newly qualified ACCA at age of 23 is a bit pie in the sky. But good luck Ben.
Would say that an ACCA qualified person (post qualified about 5 - 10 years) could expect to earn about £30k - £35k. Would say you could only expect to be earning £40k once you are in your late 30s/early 40s.
Whenever you read these surveys of what people earn you have to ask yourself who are they asking as it is certainly no one i have ever come across other than; people who are partners/directors in accounting firms or businesses in industry.
I did start to write a reply earlier but been a bit busy today and the responses that you have are actually so much better than mine was.
Don't know at all where the line came from about "It seems very much like you do not like the idea of someone young succeeding and being on the same salary as an elder adult with children?" I work with a lot of twenty somethings who work for the big four. However, they have done their time in University getting good grades followed by doing ACCA (with exemptions for their degree's). Even so, at that stage in their careers (late twenties) they are not looking at the sort of money that you have been talking about. (However, £70k+ is quite feasible later on when in more senior positions).
One thing that comes through is that you feel that we are somehow trying to put you off. That's not the case at all. We admire that at 17 you are making such plans and just want you to have facts rather than fiction as a basis for your plans.
You have been advised here by genuine people who are very respected in our respective fields and who have been there, done that. We're not just reading this off websites. We're talking from personal experience in an attempt to help you move forwards.
As Sheila briefly touched upon. Where information is derived from supervisory bodies and training providers there is an inherent ulterior motive to making things sound easier or faster than they really are... Ask yourself why it is that so many people drop out of the ACCA qualification?
I don't know where you are actually getting your information from but besides the above salary survey which I gave you (and stated the facts in black and white), also look at jobserve as this gives a good indication of the rates that companies are willing to pay.... Note that £50k pro rata for contract positions is not the same as £50k. Firstly the role will likely last less than a year and then you will likely have a gap where you receieve no money whilst you find the next position. Also, the rule of thumb is that for a contract position to be equivalent to a permanent position it needs to bring in around twice the return to end up with the same amount available for the person to actually spend (espechially true since the advent if IR35).
Whether you listen to the advice is down to you but I hope that you will take this advice as an investment that you will come back to the site and repay when you have completed your qualifications as it's only by people passing forwards their genuine experience that students will know the truth of qualifications and career expectations.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Well i had big plans to pay my mortgage off and retire all in one year but i must say that you lot have well and truly burst my bubble and piddled on my bonfire. (mind you my dreams may come true but only in my eightieth year)
-- Edited by Spamkebab on Monday 1st of August 2011 04:31:24 PM
It really doesn't make you happy anyway. You just end up agrieved at how much you are actually handing over the the government every year.
better to be happy on £30k than never seeing your children on £100k
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Ha Shaun, if i earned 30k i'd be skint and i'd never see my children anyway. Well that's what's happened on 20k so i can predict the outcome of Dad earning more. But seriously (to Ben) i'm 38 years old, have owned and managed a small business, held supervisory positions and now want to break into accounts and the only way i can see it happening is if start at purchase ledger level earning around 16k a year.
-- Edited by Spamkebab on Monday 1st of August 2011 04:48:53 PM
I think if you have those type of ambitions then you should now be approaching a big firm of accountants and telling them of your plans. If they see you as matching the ability to your ambitions they will take you on.
I actually went down a similar route to your plan, modern apprenticeship at 18, AAT then ACCA. Small gap between the two due to me not being sure. I am now self employed for the last couple of years, but my salary as an accounts manager with 10+ years experience was £38.5k.
Incidentally, I do know of one person who went down a similar route to what you are suggesting and was a partner in a good mid-tier firm at just over 30. She was very dedicated but had no social life!
__________________
Phil Hendy, The Accountancy Mentor
Are you thinking of setting up your own practice or have you set up and need some help?
If so a mentor may be the way forward - feel free to get in touch and see how I can assist you.
Thanks for all the replies. Its good that people are giving me their honest opinions other than bullshitting me to keep me in education.
Please note again I was not expecting to be on 50k at 23, but we can all dream.
I have set my sights high but I believe if you don't then you settle for below average. I plan to try and do what I can. I was also told today of someone who is a chartered accountant around my area who is on 50k+ Maybe Ill be that next lucky one?
I personally just want to be able to get into a position where I am on 40k+ on an almost 9 to 5. Also I have not decided I would dedicate my life to chartered accounting but I thought it would be a very, very good qualification to have and give me good opportunities.
Please can you guys tell me, lets say I was to have 5 years experience, what you think I would then be on as a chartered accountant? I may also gain an extra business related qualification but then, do i really want to be studying my whole life?
I just want to get the ACCA qualification under my belt and be in a position to expect 40k+ a year. My three options im seeing at the moment is through becoming a long time chartered accountant, going into management(bearing in mind I did well in my business studies) or owning my own business(maybe when Im 40+ for that one though, Want to have a life first. :)
But please reply again and just give me advise and answer the above question :)
I think the route you are planning to take is a good route in your position. As to whether £30K is a good living salary, that depends on where in the country you live, the cost of housing, either rented or on a mortgage, in that area is going to be the major outlay.
I plan to live in Milton Keynes, I do not think it is to bad for those sort of things. Bare in mind Im good at saving and dont plan to have kids anytime in the near future :)
I do find that it is hard to say what is a good salary, my family has coped well and had nice stuff on under 12k for years whereas my uncle who is on 50k says how poor he/they are. And our house is much nicer. It is down to the individual I suppose.
Too true Ben, you could give everyone in the country the same salary and at the end of a year some would have broken even, some would have savings and some would be in debt - it's all down to individuals and their spending priorities which you have pointed out in your post. It's also about living within your means (or not). Good luck with whatever you decide.
When i was 5 years post qualified as a CA i was on about £28k but that was 7 years ago so with inflation etc you would probably say about £30k a year now. That was with a CA firm in central Scotland as an accounts/audit manager.
If you want to make any money they the smart move is to move into industry within a couple of years of qualifying. Only people who become partners in CA firms make any real money in practice. But then again you have the hassle of keeping your existing clients happy and generating new business etc.
So Mark you feel the best option is to go into a finance department in a large company? What are the salaries looking at with this? I think that is quiet easy to get into once I have achieved the ACCA qualification isnt it?
How do you feel a single male living on his own would fair on a 25 grand gross salary in thier early twenties?
I'm at the stage where I can make the decisions on what route I want to take, what do you suggest?
Your first task is to pass your ACCA exams and then after that the world is your oyster. You can really do what you want.
But i think you think that passing your ACCA exams is a foregone conclusion. Cant really comment on ACCA as i went down the CA route but have worked with a lot of smart folk who struggled to pass them. Some even dropped out. I am sure that some people who have done/doing ACCA on here would give their own comments.
At the end of the day any qualification is just an indication that you have the knowledge not that you can do a particular job. Nothing beats experience and personally I would hire some who had experience/could do the job over someone who had no post qualifying experience but had an accounting qualification.
you asked about the ACCA exam and people droipping out.
taking Birmingham as an example (but assuming that this scenario is repeated accross all cities/countries).
taking the first ACCA paper the ACCA had to hire two huge halls in Birmingham for the thousand plus candidates.
Each paper after that there were less and less people sitting until at the later stages several papers are sat in the same, smaller centre at the same time.
The burn rate of students is high with a lot seeming to drop the qualification when going from the fundamentals to the skills level papers.
Fundamentals level papers are very much AAT level questions and two hour papers.
When people hit the skills level at paper F4 it's a quantum leap in what is required of students (and the papers move up to 3 hours). Many seem to struggle an attempt at this level but over the next six papers at every sitting there are fewer and fewer cars in the car park on exam days.... Conversely the quality of the cars improves dramatically so seems obvious that the survivors are getting better salaries.
It seems that by the time one gets to the advanced papers most of those who will fall out of the qualification already have and the numbers stabilise as you jump those last few hurdles. However, by this stage you've developed that distant stare that seems to be shared by shell shocked Vietnam vets and ACCA PQ's.
In Bens casegoing via AAT he would join up with exemptions so the quantum leap would come in going from AAT to ACCA level papers rather than the leap happening within the qualification... I've spoken with many students in the past and I'm still shocked at how many only look at old exam papers for F1 or F2 when signing up. Personally I regard F4 as the first ACCA paper and anything prior to that just prep work to ensure that student have the basic skills to study accountancy.
You can actually take four papers at each sitting which with Bens timescales I think is what he's looking at. However, I got some good advice once from a tutor freind (I self study rather than do courses).
"You can either fail four exams or stand a chance of passing two. Only reason ACCA let you take four is that they get to charge you again for the retakes!".
I think that there is a certain element of truth to that although it's very simplistic. There are papers that complement each other and it helps if you take them together (such as corporate reporting and Audit). But there are some papers such as corporate law that should either be taken alone or only with resits from previous failures.
I've actually read on the ACCA website that they state 3-4 years to pass the qualification. I think that if one gets exemptions from the first 3 papers (leaving 11) works hard and allows for maybe 5 resits in there 4 years is actually possible at two papers per sitting.
One line that Ben did have in his posts was about this being a 9 to 5 job.... Wonder how many people reading this thread fell off their seats laughing at that one (when they read it at work in the early hours of the morning).
My last serious girlfreind was Chartered and I seldom got to see her as it seemed that time spent with boyfreinds had to be regarded as non chargeable downtime! Seemed that we had most of our relationship on the phone at around two in the morning when I (working in high finance) would be just finishing up and she would still be alone in the office tearing her hair out whilst her staff were all snuggled in their beds.... And we were still both back at work by 08:00 the next day...
That must be one of the reasons why accountants very often marry accountants as besides clients and staff (for the good of the business neither of which should generally be considered relationship material) other accountants are the only people that you actually ever get to see!
9 to 5... Yer, right! (lol)
talk later Mark,
all the best,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I very much agree with you experience comment, as if I owned a company I would do the same thing. The thing is Ive seen this as a really good route and one that does not mean I have to go university but will still come out with a very, very well regarded qualification.
This is why I ask for both of your opinions on which route you think I should take once completing the AAT and if I should continue onto ACCA but then change direction after that by going into management or business, In todays world it seems I need to get this a recognised qualification like this as a piece of paper saying you have achieved something is what gets you the job.
when in business the bank takes you a lot more seriously when you have a serious qualification behind you.
Every day people go into the bank with no idea about finance and wonder why the bank will not support their ventures.
People with accountancy qualifications are taken a lot more seriously.
Many managers started out with accountancy qualifications. As Mark says the ACCA qualification opens a lot of doors to which I would just like to add that a lot of them are not directly related to accountancy (i.e. practice) roles.
Just because you are a manager or business owner does not mean that you cannot also be ACCA.... If I had my way it would actually be compulsory as there are so many business owners out there who are great at what the do but just don't have the first clue about how to run a business.
Having ACCA behind you will mean you will understand how to turn your business into something profitable.
Also, now your getting onto this subject a good line to take forwards with you.
"Nobody ever got rich working for someone else!".
By the way, on the ACCA instead of university thing. You do realise that once you've passed the first nine papers (provided I believe that you actually sat the first three and didn't claim them as exemptions) you can actually do a project in order to get a degree from Oxford Brookes the ACCA's affiliated university so you come away with a degree even before you have the full ACCA qualification!
The thinking behind that is that the first nine papers of ACCA are (at least) the equivalent of doing a BSc.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I agree with all of that, the only thing is, I dont really want to be 'rich' I want to be earning a good amount and comfortable, and not an extravagant life to be honest. This is why I dont want to dedicate my life to work by owning a business.
you spending your time trawling old threads now? Actually, considering the subject matter of the bulk of this thread does that mean that your looking at coming over to the dark side of accountancy... It's really cool, you get a long black cape and everything!
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.