Yeah I think it was ok, a bit different to what I expected though. Wasn't 100% about the VAT return question as there didn't seem much work for 10 marks...
And I know what you mean about the time, was rushing at the end and my trial balance didn't balance so I started correcting my errors (stupidly left the payments out of the control accounts) but didn't have time to re-draft the TB. Hopefully they will see my workings and give me marks for that even if they do have to deduct some for the TB.
Only a month to wait for the results...Oh well, at least it's all over now. And relax....! :)
I've done a number of past papers and always thought that the allocation of marks was odd. 20 marks for filling in a VAT form but only 25 for opening a whole set of accounts and updating with TB before and after. One takes 15 minutes at most, the other about an hour.
Oh well. Let's hope we never have to worry about this exam again.
There's a general mood of despair on the HLC Forum following the exam. The Question of Bad Debt Relief on a VAT return was not covered in the HLC course materials.
I'm fortunate to have come across it while doing a past paper and think I've dealt with it correctly.
Yes I agree. I also studied with HLC (my tuition has expired hence I can no longer access the forums!) and did not cover bad debt on a VAT return. I took a bit of a guess and looking it up afterwards I think I have gone along the right lines. Here's hoping anyway.
At least I feel a bit better about the mark allocation though, thanks Neil!
i did exam yesterday an wow....i flunked it my course hadnt covered for most which is nuts in a way i bought a past paper an revised everything on the syllabus...an i think i over did the revision so much my mind went blank on some of the things the control accounts i looked at an had i went with my gut feeling i would have got it right...but i didnt for me tit went downhill a bit from then on....i know i flunked it but now its given me a huge kick an i will prepare an put in for the exam again in june i hope everyone did ok in theirs June
I wouldn't get down hearted just yet. When I did my level II I came out absolutely convinced I had failed, which was reinforced when I got home and went through the questions and realised my mistakes.
I remember that my trial balance didn't, lots of crossing out of calculations and I had to rush the last questions.
Spent the next month really dreading the result dropping through the letter box (no online results at that time).
You could have knocked me down with a feather when I did get the result because I had passed.
I'd carry on with level III studies and brush up on any area you struggled with. I am sure we all have our fingers crossed for all of you that sat exams yesterday.
Hi Bill the only problem is ...i didnt finish 2 questions an the the first question i got totally wrong because i couldnt see the mistakes, it was on control accounts, an was asked to corect the entires as there were mistakes...if i had gone with my gut instinct, i would have got it right...so in fact, 3 out of 5 questions werent completed at all i came home pretty down but im gonna prepare properly an will put in for the exam in level 2 in june...i already have level 2 in computerised im not gonna do level 3 yet as im going into payroll instead which im starting in a months time
I'm sorry to hear that you had such a bad time in the exam.
If it turns out you have failed and you need to resit, could I recommend that you use the ICB past papers? I did each of them under exam conditions and it both gave me practice in areas that are regularly examined and also made me aware of my weak areas.
Although there was an unusually phrased VAT question yesterday, all of the papers I have seen included basics such as trial balance, opening and updating accounts from cash book and day books, preparation of TP&L and balance sheet and journal entries to correct errors. Although there are things you need to know, it is a practical exam and you need to practice the skills which you wont have from using accounting software.
an excellent book for revising for ICB level II (and III for that matter) is the AAT - 1-4 Foundation: Revision Companion.
Any version post 2006 is great.
Comes with 23 short chapters each handling a specific topic then four full simulations followed by four practice exams.
Remember that you haven't failed until the results drop on your doorstep. I've been totally shocked in both directions before.
Talk soon,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Along with the other good advise, can I suggest you also have a look on the ICB website and read the examiners comment from past exams as they highlight areas where others have struggled.
I feel like it went ok for me, but I won't count my chickens. I was really surprised that there was only me and another woman sitting the exam in Sheffield (unless there are other centres, but the one I went to was in the city centre).
It may sound like overkill, but I did four mock exams and I'm really glad I did. It helped to prepare me for what they might ask. The first two I did were from 2007/08 and didn't include any questions on depreciation or control accounts, which surprised me. However, I then did the February and October exams from last year and found that the exams had gone up a level, and did include those aspects.
I was a little thrown at first by the the control account and VAT questions on the exam last week. I didn't expect them to give me examples to correct, but I think I managed it. I agree about the bad debt relief though - that wasn't in my coursework either (I'm with Ideal Schools).
I expect your course books were the same as mine and was covered in lesson 4? I couldn't find any reference to bad debt relief in the course work and the ICB website syllabus only mentions the basics (See extract below)
VAT Returns 1) Show an understanding of the requirements for making VAT returns 2) Prepare VAT returns 3) Explain the balancing figure on the VAT return and its implications for the business
When I did mine I think there was only a couple of people doing level II (did mine in Plymouth - which covers Cornwall and Plymouth area)
Bill, I think it was lesson 4, yes. I suppose they just expect us to use our common sense to answer that question!
I went to the exam with the expectation of it being like a school hall with lots of people sat behind desks, and then there were only the two of us. Sounds like your experience was the same.
And yes I am a cat lover - I have two of them
-- Edited by nicx27 on Monday 15th of February 2010 03:22:52 PM
hi all i too sat the exam last week and all i can say was wow that was a struggle!!! neil i agree hlc materials havent really covered much regarding bad debt relief on the vat return, actually only 5 pages on a vat return which from my point of view isnt exactly that much, (not considering 1 whole page is actually a vat 100 form, and 1 is the answer of the working out!!!
i felt quite confident when i sat down to actually sit it, thought i'd done quite well until i actually ran out of time on the last question, and then found out that i did the vat return wrong i didnt use box 4 or 7 in regards to the bad debt!!!
now i feel quite annoyed, mostly at myself but partly at the whole thing, am now considering not even re sitting if i've failed, mainly because of all the extra expense that i cant afford. frustrated is my fave word right now!!!!
sorry for ranting everybody i'm in agreement with 'shamus', when are the icb going to stop moving the goal posts?? seems like if / when i pass level 2 i am going to have to pay out even more to do level 3 (which i thought i had actually signed up for but turns out i didnt!!) and then i've got to pay out for the computerised side of it too!!!
dont suppose anyone on here knows how to get all that free or as cheap as possible without having to sign up with another provider?
I'm sure that you've done better than you think that you have.
For the computerised side :
The cheap as possible route to certification is to get a trial copy of Sage line 50 and the ICB practice exam and work through it until your results come out the same as theirs and you can understand exactly what they are looking for.
A better approach would additionally be to get the BPP AAT foundation bookkeeping with Sage and spreadsheets with Excel. That takes you through doing the books for a small company and is an excellent book for referal or revision.
There's no requirement at all with the ICB to have a training provider for any of their exams (but companies such as HLC are trying to keep that a secret).
For The Manual side :
Business Accounts by David Cox is an excellent book for around £20.
Combine that with some recent past level III papers (which you have to pay for) and download some of the CAT papers with answers from the ACCAglobal website (which you don't have to pay for).
Here's the link for that one : http://www.accaglobal.com/students/cat/exams/
The CAT papers are at a higher level then the ICB but that should just give you more confidence when going into the exam.
Alternatively vote with your feet and sign up to study CAT. It's hard work but it's the equivalent of the AAT qualification.
As far as I know you can self study CAT but you need a training provider if you go AAT so CAT is the cheaper of those two routes.
Whatever route you choose good luck with it.
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Hi I sat the ICB2 manual in Oct in Plymouth ( 3 of us ) came out and thought .....Petty Cash oops so basic,learned it, looked at past papers and thought never!!! yet VAT, P & L, BS etc Control A/C's's no problem, the thought of failing over petty cash!....yet ended up with 96%...so keep an upper chin!!!! Steve
If you look on the ICB website, they have a new area which looks at many different areas for the exams, a kind of revision area. It goes through many areas including the Bad Debt for VAT returns. As mentioned before, there is also an area about previous exams and which areas were poorly done.
I think as part of your revision, you should look at these pages together with past mock papers from ICB, to get a feel of their exam style.
I am still unsure of what the ICB want someone like me to do with no manual exams completed. Anyone got an update?
I am sorry to say that I have no update on this situation either, I was on the phone to them earlier this week about my practice licence and whilst I was talking to them thought I would see what progress was being made and guess what, still no news
I'm very excited because I just checked my results (for the 4th time today, I was getting very impatient) and they have come through!! I got 86% distinction!!! Very pleased with myself after the panic over the Bad Debt in the VAT return question and not finishing the last question! Hope everyone else is pleased with their results.
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I'm new to commenting on the forum, but have been viewing for a couple of months now.
Just wanted to say Hi. I'm Charlene, been studying with Ideal Schools for the ICB Dipolma in Manual Book Keeping. I live in Canada. Moved here last April and decided to keep studying with them. I just sat the Level 3 manual paper on 10th Feb.
Logged in to the ICB web site and found my results are in! How quick was that? So pleased, got 96%!! OMG!!
Just wanted to say Ideal Schools are excellent and well deserve the Lucas award they got in 2009. My results have been great, Level 1 100%, Level 2 98% and now 96% on Level 3 and only paid £489 to do all three courses. If I can do it, so can most!
I really enjoy the posts on the forum and thank you all for sharing your knowledge, especially with us newbies!
Well, that's just typical. I've been checking the ICB website every 3 minutes since Feb 10th and I missed being first to the results because I was on the train.
Congratulations to you both.
I also got a distinction with 100% on Level II.
Just as well. Like Shaun, I'd have lost sleep wondering where any lost marks went.
congratulations to everyone else who passed as well.
And to our newbie Welsh Canadian... What occurin!
Welcome to the forum. Bet your glad to have all of the manual side out of the way now.
kind regards,
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Definately glad they're out of the way. I was thinking about doing the Computerised exams, but as I'm now in Canada, am looking for a course that would be more beneficial over here.
From looking at job postings they mostly use Quickbooks or Sage Accpac or Simply Accounting.
I've got a little experience using UK Quickbooks, so hope I can sercure a job first and hopefully the employer will pay for the full training. Am looking forward to getting some experience and then setting up on my own in a couple of years.
Finding this site very good for info though. Great to have somewhere to bounce ideas and share knowledge.
hi all would just like to congratulations to all who have passed level 2 manual!! myself included!!! could not get my hat on i tell you was so surprised, really thought i had failed, i got 84% merit !!! not as good as i would have liked, neil wanna swap grades??? only joking!! now i'm stuck on computer as my big head wont fit through the door!!!! yay yay yay!!!
also have just got to share this, i went for a job interview yesterday, it was for a cleaning company, and for some mad reason they were more interested in my bookkeeping and i may just get the opportunity to work in bookkeeping even though i had initially gone with the intention of being a cleaner!!! so i was also very pleased about that too!!! congratulations to all i'm going to dance around the house with my duster now!!! hope you all have a good day and weekend kal x x x
neil tthank you!! cant believe i'm now actually over qualified for a job!!! there is hope out there for those of us who left school as teenagers without a clue as to what to do with their lives, (for me that was becoming a teenage mom, and doing any jobs i could to fit around when my daughter was at school!!) thats why cleaning is second nature, bit obsessive especially plug holes and handles dirty things!!! thanks again Neil and of course i'll let you all know how it goes kal x
I used to tutor for the Open University. The single most rewarding aspect of that job was seeing women who'd left school and started families discovering that they were much brighter and more able than they'd thought or been led to believe.
I think you could be in for a nice trip. Keep us posted.
Nice to see that there can be light at the end of the tunnel, I became a mum at the age of 19 (She's 21 now and at uni studying law) but I also have another 3 the youngest being 2 and he starts nursery in september which is when my light starts to come closer. I do currently work part time but only a few hours to keep my hand in while being at home with him, I did put him in nursery when I worked more hours but found I was only working to line the nursery's pocket seen as we get no help from tax credits.
Even though the forum can be distracting from studying it has also given me a bigger push to keep at it.
I too passed the level II manual - I got 90% (although I don't understand how that is showing as a distinction !) - I did my level II Computerised and got that result at the same time ! (Got 98% OMG !)
So now AICB !!
Looking at going through with paroll and Level III now !
hi all, just an update really, and a small query!!! well i've been offered 4 hours a week doing the companys bookkeeping, not too sure as to what that may entail as i'm not meeting up with the accountant til maybe next week. i just hope that what they want me to do i can do!! my query is - can i do it? what i mean is do i still need to have pii insurance? (the company already have this!) or am i covered by the companys/ accountants? also do i still have to register for mlr? i just really wanted to make sure before i go in, (unpaid at 1st, til the accountants showed me the software!! big gulp!!! give me a pen and paper anyday!!!). so basically i'd be doing a few hours bookkeeping for them and making the rest of the hours up doing cleaning, which i dont really mind as i was hoping to get a job in a small office doing the 'hands on' bookkeeping, and now i've got that opportunity, i just dont want to mess it up!!! i think i may be on here a lot in the next few weeks asking ' how do i do this???!!! thanks all kal x x
Well done Kal, that's great news. I get the impression this under PAYE, in which case you will not have to bother with MLR or PII, however if it is as self employed then yes you will need MLR and it would be wise to have PII.
I'm sure you will be more than capable of doing the job, but we are all here to chip in with ideas should you need any assistance. Once again, well done!
thanks rob, i dont think its as self employed, apparantly its because the company is growing and the accountant needs help with the bookkeeping side of things, thanks again kal x