Hi all I recently started working at a company as their Bookkeeper. On being there only a short time I have been very unhappy about the state of the business and would like to leave. I am self employed and have no contract I am on a verbal trial period and that is it.
The company is in severe financial difficulties (VAT and NI Unpaid for last quarter) and money owed of over £70k for very overdue supplier invoices. Bank account up to overdraft of £25,000.00 Despite my warnings the Director has not yet contacted HMRC to explain the non payments.
Last month the staff were all paid late, and my invoice was paid in 3 small amounts over a period of about a week. The bailiffs have come to the office twice and removed lots of items but it was for a debt connected to another company which the director of the company I am working for also trades from out of the same building. The first debt of £25000.00 was from a disgruntled contractor who was owed money and was never paid.
I see no orders coming in to even cover part of what is owed and I am very uncomfortable working for them now, as I see it only getting much worse.
My question is, what notice period do I have to give? As I stated above I am self employed and have only what was verbally agreed in my interview which was my hourly rate and my hours 9-3 Monday to Friday.
I have worked there since the 11th of April this year.
That doesn't sound as though you are really self employed but are rather helping the client to reduce their costs by working on that basis (be careful!). Of course I am only reading what is written here rather than the reality of your business.
How many other clients do you have?
Were you placed through an agent or directly?
If you are self employed and they are a client then legally you must have MLR cover and you will have looked into the company before taking up the engagement.
If you are in fact a temp employee then is not the notice period equivalent to your payment schedule. i.e. weekly paid workers have seven days notice, monthly paid workers a month.
The above said, a struggling client is not in itself a reason to abandon them. They are at least attempting to pay you.
Is the problem that they themselves are awaiting large payments?
You are the bookkeeper, I assume that you can read financial statements. How do the unpublished figures (not just the cash) look?
Lack of cash kills healthy businesses but so does losing staff members. Before running ensure that you are 100% sure what you are running away from.
As a footnote, in future ensure that you always get a signed engagement letter with every client and always do your due dilligence per your MLR requirements. Such is not just be considered a rubber stamping excercise.
Shaun.
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
Hi Shaun, Thank you for your reply. I am self employed and have been since 2008. I have two other clients who I do bookkeeping for but these I do from my office at home. I do comply with MLR and have since going SE in Jan 2008.
The company has only recently got into difficulties, as it was only recently bought by a new director, so on initial investigation there were no significant red flags, and I am aware many companies go through periods of hardship. The company itself has been trading for some 30 years with no issues as the previous owner still comes in to help, or did before all his testing equipment was taken by the bailiff and the last 3 months invoices haven't been paid for some £16,000 so he is now refusing to do any more work for the company and is very angry at how the business is now being run and how the staff are being treated.
last month the new director called one member of staff and said there was only enough money to pay one member of staff and she would have to chose between it being her or another member of staff. Who does that ??
The new director will not agree to me invoicing them weekly so I am concerned I will expose myself to month of work and not get paid at the end of it.
The issue as I see it is with the new owner/Director
Hi Sarah
First thing that grabbed me was the ir35 issue, but will await the answers to the questions raised by Shaun.
Also, worth adding Ive worked with businesses who have been losing money hand over fist, all looks a bit dire, heads buried in the sand initially but the best part of this job in many ways is being able to spot the issues and help them resolve it, see where costs can be cut, improvements to pricing and sales and cashflows can be made as often folk just need someone else to help them see the wood form the trees.
Would you be able to help them with such? You have put given us the usual into, so perhaps when you have what you need from this/before a next posting you let us have such....background-how long in business as a bookkeeper, qualifications, what prof body, doing any other exams and which body, career before you became a bookkeeper, where based....that sort of thing, as it helps to get to know you and pitch answers better.
For this one, as long as they are paying you, then stick it out, what have you got to lose? Maybe a day or twos income? Or all of it if you just give up.
First question....why do you think they are getting no orders? What can they do to improve that? (What sector?) out of interest too how long has this business been around and is it a fairly recent issue they have been having with cashflow?
When does your trial period end? Do they have an Accountant? Have you had a very frank discussion with the boss or just mentioned things in passing?
__________________
Joanne
Winner of Bookkeeper of the Year 2015, 2016 & 2017
Thoughts are my own/not to be regarded as official advice,which should be sought from a suitably qualified Accountant.
You should check out answers with reference to the legal position
There is a clear if 35 issue to my mind, that needs resolving.
What were your terms to start with, verbal are as good in that case. If you stated weekly then that's what they are. If you agreed to monthly then you are stuck with it without renegotiation. So renegotiate, as that is your potential for a get out.
Whose testing equipment was taken by the bailiff? The old directors personal equipment or was it the businesses? Surely if it's the former he has a case to get it back!!
Will leave you to answer the other Qs for now.
__________________
Joanne
Winner of Bookkeeper of the Year 2015, 2016 & 2017
Thoughts are my own/not to be regarded as official advice,which should be sought from a suitably qualified Accountant.
You should check out answers with reference to the legal position
Thank you both for your input, I will try and answer all I can.
I work self employed so I am ST trading as AA and I do a self assessment return at the end of each year, I do not have a Ltd Company. Since going SE in 2008 I have done small jobs for local small businesses mostly working from home.
I have worked in Accounting since 1989 and would be what one would call QBE but I would always work alongside an Accountant with either the Accountant of the firm I am working for OR my own Accountant who is there for financial support and advice,
I am not a member of any Accounting body but to my knowledge I do not need to be and have always been clear about that when taking on any new work. I do mostly lower level stuff such as processing invoices and bank recs that sort of thing. I do not offer payroll services and do not give Tax advice.
In the interview we didn't agree any terms re invoicing, he just said he would like to me start immediately and that he would try and accommodate the hourly rate I asked for which was £20 however he backtracked when I first invoiced at that rate and said he would pay me £18 ph for the first month and then reassess the situation which never happened.
No hours, or notice period or billing frequency was agreed either as it was more of an informal chat but I left having been offered the position. The last lady who had been there was stealing money form the business so had been sacked and the accounts were in a mess. I have spent nearly 2 months re-inputting all the invoices and bank into Xero from the beginning of Jan 2017 as last years accounts were on Sage line 100 a DOS version.
The testing equipment was owned personally by the previous owner but as it was taken with lots of other items the bailiff refuse to split the seize, but this is all being dealt with by the company solicitors.
I know there are no orders as I also help out on the sales ordering system and their margins are very small, the new director offers huge discounts and asks all the customers to pay on proforma.
I can see he is doing what he can to help the business, but he recently went to Las Vegas for 10 days to a 5 day conference all on company expenses which would have been fine if the business was doing okay, but as we barely do any business in the US it felt a little indulgent when the staff were not getting paid.
Perhaps I am being a little hasty in thinking of leaving I am generally one for loyalty but something about this situation is not sitting right with me.
I have been trying to help them save money by looking at all expenditure and working out what is needed and what is not, renegotiating contracts with suppliers etc
There are only 2 other members of staff who have both only been there since the new director came on board and both are considering leaving as they are so unhappy.
When he backtracked on the first invoice rate, what happened re the conversation you had with him? How long have you worked for this new chap?
Have you had a full and frank discussion with him - ie pinned him down, proper meeting, laid out all the evidence eg shown him exactly on a few invoices what his low margin is and that by discounting them further the exact loss per job, plus factor in the overheads? Overall loss to date/increases is losses over the last few months showing exactly where his issues lie. Plus sitting there whilst he puts the call out to HMRC. Plus telling him that the whole trip to LA is going to his DLA as there was no justification in it. What has been done to recover the money stolen?
__________________
Joanne
Winner of Bookkeeper of the Year 2015, 2016 & 2017
Thoughts are my own/not to be regarded as official advice,which should be sought from a suitably qualified Accountant.
You should check out answers with reference to the legal position
There are no future sales on the cash flow, we are working on a day by day basis and orders are coming in on average for £500 we then order the goods from China, Korea etc for around about £400 and ship to customer our margins are very small. Of course the director keeps telling us he has an order coming in over the next few weeks for £330k but sadly no one believes him. He is prone to fabrication. He told the other members of staff it was my fault they didn't get paid and yet I collected in all outstanding debts from customers there was nothing more I could have done, I cant generate sales.
Hes now taken on a Chairman who specialises in factoring invoices and we are paying him £500 a day. But as all our customers pay on proforma I see it as a waste of money.
-- Edited by AccountingAdmin on Tuesday 30th of May 2017 10:22:49 AM
I have tried to talk to him but he just says we will chat again another time, he avoids any conversations about money. I have been there less than 2 months and feel i have no power as he will listen to what I suggest re HMRC etc and agree to it, but then does nothing about it, it is incredibly frustrating as I feel powerless to sort things out.
When he said he would pay me £18 an hour I replied by email that I would accept £18ph for the first month and then we would reassess when he came back form Las Vegas and he has as yet to sit down with me to discuss it. As there is virtually no money in the company I felt it would be a fruitless exercise to try and up my rate to £20 so have not pushed the subject.
I am not good with confrontation and feel he knows this and has deliberately avoided all conversations about it.
I invoiced last week for May which was £1500 and asked him if he would pay at least half of my invoice on Friday and he paid me £150.
There is just no money in the bank to pay me or the staff, we have £3500 coming in tomorrow so the staff and I may get paid but this also means the VAT and NI will not, nor will our suppliers and there are no other orders on the sales book to come in or be paid now.
The money that was stolen was an odd issue, he told me she was stealing outright but the other lady who works there said the last Bookkeeper wanted to be paid weekly (presumably as she could see what was happening to the finances) but he said no, so she went ahead and did it anyway, then billed at the end of the month, so technically it was her money but she just went about it in an illegal way so no money is due to be recovered.
This site reminds me everyday why not to work with small companies...
__________________
Shaun
Responses are not meant as a substitute for professional advice. Answers are intended as outline only the advice of a qualified professional with access to all relevant information should be sought before acting on any response given.
I have to say in the 9 years I have been self employed or indeed the previous 16 years as an employee this is the first time I have had these issues, I guess I have been fortunate up until now.
Im sure you have learnt a lot from taking this one though Sarah. Not a good way to learn such, I know, but certainly take heed of what Shaun suggests for your next role, plus get yourself on the firms own books as an employee when there are clear IR35 issues.
Problem you have now is that effectively you have agreed to a change of contract by accepting the £18, although there might be an argument for him now accepting the revised rate back up to £20 as I am assuming when he part paid it he did not dispute the invoice. But that as Shaun suggests means you would really need to give a months notice. But like I said - you may need to force his hand. Whilst not being confrontational in the past, surely not being paid £1350 would get you that way. Get your list of arguments together and pin him down. As I said, its probably your best get out. Timing is everything. Think I would be feeling a bit sick for a day or three. But certinaly not tomorrow if he is likely to pay a chunk more (tomorrow hopefully). I suspect some of this you will have to take as an expensive lesson, although of course you should still persue any unpaid bills bia the usual processes (its worth a couple of quid for a solicitors letter idc if needs be!)
Is this Chairman a mate of his?
You may need to consider MLR!!
__________________
Joanne
Winner of Bookkeeper of the Year 2015, 2016 & 2017
Thoughts are my own/not to be regarded as official advice,which should be sought from a suitably qualified Accountant.
You should check out answers with reference to the legal position
Thank you Joanne yes it has been a huge learning curve for me and I really appreciate having this forum to air my concerns. I think I will look to getting my invoice paid this month and then move on to pastures new. I will give notice out of courtesy but doubt I will get paid for that as there are a list as long as my arm of people chasing him for money, personally and through the business.
The Chairman is about 80 years old and has worked for 40 years helping businesses find factoring companies and also investor funding but he is asking for a set of accounts to produce to potential investors in a few months but unless they can generate some decent orders I cannot imagine anyone would want to invest. I don't know if they have a personal relationship but as we have never had a problem getting money in from our customers I cannot see how paying the man £1000 a month for 2 days work could possibly benefit us right now if he is purely looking at factoring. He is a nice enough chap but sales is what we need !
I really appreciate your help and advice on this matter, also to you Shaun.